Author Archives: jdingel

Dead Aid

Out this week is Dead Aid by Zambian economist and former World Bank consultant Dambisa Moyo. She’s hawking a tough sell – not merely arguing that aid has had negligible impact on average, Moyo is pressing the case that aid has been “an unmitigated political, economic, and humanitarian disaster“:

The aid money pouring into Africa, she says, underwrites brutal and corrupt regimes; it stifles investment; and it leads to higher rates of poverty — all of which, in turn, creates a demand for yet more aid. Africa, Ms. Moyo notes, seems hopelessly trapped in this spiral, and she wants to see it break free. Over the past 30 years, she says, the most aid-dependent countries in Africa have experienced economic contraction averaging 0.2% a year. [WSJ book review]

The Wall Street Journal published an excerpt (the book’s preface) this morning, but that passage doesn’t even begin to make the anti-aid argument. But Bill Easterly is excited about the book, so it’s probably worth a closer look.

Update: See this (negative) review. Thanks to Luis Enrique in the comments for the pointer.

Mexican trucks and NAFTA obligations

Trade spat!

The Mexican government said Monday it would slap tariffs on 90 U.S. industrial and agricultural products, in a trade dispute that underscored the difficulties facing President Barack Obama as he tries to assure business and global allies that he favors free trade.

Mexico said the tariffs were in retaliation for the cancellation of a pilot program allowing Mexican trucks to transport cargo throughout the U.S.

Unions have for years fought to keep Mexican trucks off U.S. highways, despite longstanding agreements by the two countries to eventually allow their passage. Legislation killing the pilot program was included in a $410 billion spending bill Mr. Obama signed last week.

Tidbits

  • Language as a trade barrier – “[I]f knowledge of English in all European countries increased by ten percentage points, European trade would rise by up to 15% on average. Bringing all European countries up to the level of English proficiency enjoyed by the Dutch could increase European trade by up to 70%.”
  • The third edition of Doug Irwin‘s Free Trade Under Fire will be out in a few months.
  • Foreign athletes can now play in the US for more than ten years.
  • Robert Baldwin criticizes the botched special safeguard mechanism that caused so much trouble for the Doha negotiations back in July.
  • The benefits of highly skilled immigration: “If immigrants were merely displacing natives, increases in the H-1B quota should not have led to increases in innovation. But Messrs Kerr and Lincoln found that when the federal government increased the number of people allowed in under the programme by 10%, total patenting increased by around 2% in the short run. This was driven mainly by more patenting by immigrant scientists. But even patenting by native scientists increased slightly, rather than decreasing as proponents of crowding out would have predicted.”

Financial crisis and manufacturing exports

Mark Koyama notes that manufacturing-driven economies are being hit pretty hard by the financial crisis:

Countries which retained significant manufacturing industries like Germany and particularly Japan are currently suffering the most – even though their banks were cautiously managed unlike much of the Anglo-American financial sector.  Japan’s GDP shrunk at an annualized rate of 12.7 percent last quarter which more or less wipes out the growth that took place between 2003 and 2007.   Since it is very easy to defer purchasing a new mp3 player or car, while expenditures on services are harder to cut back on, the bulk of the fall in aggregate demand has manifest itself in terms of falling demand for manufactured products. Development economists in the 1960s used to advice developing countries that it was dangerous to specialize in a single cash crop like coffee despite what comparative advantage might say because it would leave the entire economy dependent on movements in global prices. Now it appears that economies that have specialized in exporting manufactured are  peculiarly vulnerable in a world where globalization has meant that economic shocks are tightly correlated across countries.